The Backslider is probably the most notorious Mormon novel ever written--even though most Latter-day Saints have never heard of it. It's about a cowboy in southern Utah named Frank Windham who believes in God, but wants nothing to do with him. For the first half of the novel, he's doing everything he can to hide from God and run away from Jesus. Then, when his brother castrates himself (yeah...this is a weird novel, folks), he turns around and tries to live the gospel with exactness. The only problem is, Frank thinks he's eternally damned if he slips up even once. He begins to keep a tally of his sins, and he eventually resorts to punishing his body with a vegetable grater, among other things, rather than repenting and accepting the grace of God.
Vernal Promises, in many ways, is a less irreverent version of The Backslider. It's the story of dazed and confused Jacob Israel Dennison, another backsliding Mormon, who has a hard time saying no to drugs (and beer). Like Frank, he's convinced that he's got to save himself through his deeds alone, that he's not worthy of grace. After his wife miscarries, he returns to church and tries to live right, but he gets frustrated and soon goes back to his old ways. Most of the novel is lost in the fog of Jacob's drug habit--he's gets high in nearly every chapter, including an intense chapter that involves LSD, meth, homemade fajitas, and a gun--but it does have some profound moments of clarity.
Of the two novels, The Backslider is the better-written, although its characters and situations are often (and intentionally) exaggerated and sensationalized--which is actually part of its charm. Vernal Promises, despite its strong start, becomes less polished as it progresses. By the end of the book, in fact, the story becomes either too melodramatic or sentimental for my tastes. I also think it fails to take advantage of the dramatic potential of some of its later plot developments. Still, its characters are interesting enough to make you want to keep reading. Jacob's wife, Pam, is possibly the most real character in the novel.
Of course, I should probably say that I'm hesitant to recommend either novel, although both have their merits. The Backslider, like I said, is a pretty notorious Mormon novel. Frank Windham embraces the sinful life, and Peterson has no qualms about depicting it. So, obviously, The Backslider is not for everyone. Vernal Promises, on the other hand, is more discreet in its depiction of sin, although Harrell's descriptions of drug abuse will probably get you high just from reading them. Of course, that's not why I would hesitate to recommend Vernal Promises. Honestly, if you're only going to read one Mormon novel this year, there are better Mormon novels out there. (However, if you're going to read three or four...)
To their credit, though, both novels get you thinking deeply about the atonement of Jesus Christ. All to often, as Mormons, we worry about being perfect. We look at our own failures, compare them to the apparent successes of others, and chastise ourselves for not being good enough. Like Frank, we keep tallies of our failings and despair when we slip up or fall short of our unrealistic expectations. Worse, we frequently end up punishing ourselves--often mentally--when, really, it's not our job to do that. Or, like Pam in Vernal Promises, we repent of past transgressions, but refuse to believe, deep down, that Christ can remove the stains of sin. Like her, we wonder "Why couldn't there be a world where people just stayed clean forever?" not realizing that a world like that could never lead us to exaltation (249).
One of the most meaningful scenes in Vernal Promises occurs near the end of the novel. Jacob has slipped up again, so he drives off into the desert to end his life as a kind of sacrifice for his own sins. Of course, his bishop catches up with him, although not until after Jacob has seriously injured himself. On the way to the hospital, as Jacobs goes in and out of consciousness, the bishop confesses to his own failings as a father and to the part he played in his son's loss of faith. His point is that no one, no matter how perfect they seem to be, is exempt from the struggles of mortal life. "Everyone's got a mess to deal with," the bishop tells Jacob. "Your no different" (328).
Which is true. It's my bet that all the perfect-seeming people at church each have problems I'd rather not deal with. As Jack Harrell, author of Vernal Promises, recently pointed out on Dawning of a Brighter Day, Mormons generally try to put their best faces forward. These are the public faces that we see "at the ward meetinghouse, on the home or visiting teaching visit, or in the family when we believe others are watching." While our intentions are mostly good for putting these faces on, they often work to cover up the very real fact that we are humans with more problems in our basements than food storage. Sadly, this gap between our public and private selves can lead to a lot of misunderstandings. If anything, The Backslider and Vernal Promises expose the dangers of believing this gap doesn't exist.
More importantly, though, these novel remind us that Christ lived a perfect life so that we don't have to--which should be good news for all of us, whether we believe it or not.